Gavin Maclure's Musings

My take on politics locally, nationally and internationally

Cameron reshuffles the pack


One thing that struck me about today’s Cabinet reshuffle is the deliberate drama played out by the Prime Minister of the day. In a parliamentary democracy, the PM doesn’t really have much power. Unlike the President of the United States, he can’t even go to war without some jumped-up backbencher from Nowheresville North having a vote on it. But when it comes to deciding who has a Government job or not, the Prime Minister has real power – his word is final.

However, today’s reshuffle took the best part of a day to complete. It’s not as if ministers who got sacked only found out today. They knew yesterday or even before. But we still had to see grinning winners like Theresa Villiers and Jeremy Hunt traipsing up Downing Street to “find out” what David Cameron wanted to see them about. I suppose a bit of drama is necessary: who was it that said politics is showbusiness for ugly people?
Anyway, down to business. This is the make-up of the new Coalition Cabinet:
Prime Minister, First Lord of the Treasury and Minister for the Civil Service –The Rt Hon David Cameron MP
Deputy Prime Minister, Lord President of the Council – The Rt Hon Nick Clegg MP
Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs – The Rt Hon William Hague MP
Chancellor of the Exchequer – The Rt Hon George Osborne MP
Chief Secretary to the Treasury – The Rt Hon Danny Alexander MP
Lord Chancellor, Secretary of State for Justice – The Rt Hon Chris Grayling MP
Secretary of State for the Home Department; and Minister for Women and Equalities – The Rt Hon Theresa May MP
Secretary of State for Defence – The Rt Hon Philip Hammond MP
Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills – The Rt Hon Dr Vincent Cable MP
Secretary of State for Work and Pensions – The Rt Hon Iain Duncan Smith MP
Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change – The Rt Hon Edward Davey MP
Secretary of State for Health – The Rt Hon Jeremy Hunt MP
Secretary of State for Education – The Rt Hon Michael Gove MP
Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government – The Rt Hon Eric Pickles MP
Secretary of State for Transport – The Rt Hon Patrick McLoughlin MP
Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs – The Rt Hon Owen Paterson MP
Secretary of State for International Development – The Rt Hon Justine Greening MP
Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport – The Rt Hon Maria Miller MP
Secretary of State for Northern Ireland – The Rt Hon Theresa Villiers MP
Secretary of State for Scotland – The Rt Hon Michael Moore MP
Secretary of State for Wales – The Rt Hon David Jones MP
Minister without Portfolio – The Rt Hon Grant Shapps MP
Minister without Portfolio – The Rt Hon Ken Clarke QC MP
Leader of the House of Lords, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster – The Rt Hon Lord Strathclyde
Leader of the House of Commons, Lord Privy Seal – The Rt Hon Andrew Lansley MP
Minister for the Cabinet Office, Paymaster General – The Rt Hon Francis Maude MP
Attorney General – The Rt Hon Dominic Grieve QC MP
Solicitor General – The Rt Hon Oliver Heald MP
Chief Whip (Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury) – The Rt Hon Andrew Mitchell
The Liberal Democrats have been left in place. Outside of the Cabinet, David Laws has risen from the political dead and becomes an Education Minister, which looks likely to be cover for doing fix-its jobs for Clegg and Cameron across Government. As Harry Cole from the Guido Fawkes blog said, some MPs didn’t spend two years on the backbenchers after fiddling their expenses, they spent time at Her Majesty’s Pleasure. But, hey, if you’re liked by the top brass, you get a pass!
Andrew Lansley has been sacked as Health Secretary and, strangely, Jeremy Hunt, who was Rupert Murdoch’s mole in the UK Government during his botched takeover of BSkyB, wasn’t sacked for corruption, he was promoted today to laud over the NHS. What does the guy need to do to get sacked? In Hunt’s case, it may be what he knows that is keeping him in the Government and in a very senior position at that.
The Government’s position on airport expansion was partially revealed today by the side-ways shift for Justine Greening who moves from Transport to International Development. Miss Greening is adamantly opposed to a third runway at Heathrow and has campaigning heavily on the subject in her constituency, Putney, which sits in the flight-path for Heathrow. Now she’s gone, the Government is likely to seriously look at the third runway option again, which in my view is the wrong approach, as I’ve written here.
A notable move is that of Ken Clarke who has been sacked from Justice and given a non-job as “Minister Without Portfolio”, which means he can attend Cabinet. To do what, I don’t know. But Ken’s seen it all before so no doubt he can offer pearls of wisdom to the public school boys around the the Cabinet table. Frankly, he is probably the only person in Government who has a clue about economics but dumping Osborne was never an option for Cameron, however many British people boo him at a global event.
A major change in the organisation of the Conservative Party was made today in that the hapless Baroness Warsi was given the boot and was replaced by über-moderniser and Cameroon loyalist Michael Green Grant Shapps. I’m not sure that will go down very well with the grassroots. Warsi was dreadful as Party Chairman but she was from the same mould as Hunt, Cameron and Shapps. Cameron’s Government doesn’t reflect the Conservative Party membership or the country and having a Government-man like Shapps telling the members in not so unsubtle terms that we are the reason why the General Election was lost in 2010 is really not going to go down well amongst the voluntary party. Let’s hope he doesn’t equate UKIP to the BNP!
A number of the 2010 Conservative intake have been given jobs today including former GMTV presenter Esther McVey, who becomes Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Work and Pensions (the lowest rung on the Government ladder), and Anna Soubry who will join Jeremy Hunt’s team at Health, also as a Parliamentary Under Secretary of State.
Osborne’s former bodyguard Chloe Smith moves from the treasury to take a few bullets for Francis Maude in the Cabinet Office, where he is pretending to slim down the Civil Service. Sajid Javid replaces Miss Smith becoming the new Economic Secretary to the Treasury.
At the time of writing, it is not known if Ipswich MP Ben Gummer has received a call from Downing Street.

Author: gavinmaclure

IT professional; political blogger, former Conservative councillor

4 thoughts on “Cameron reshuffles the pack

  1. What a load of old tripe Gavin. I'm sorry, but really? I didn't realise you were writing Ed Milibands speeches for him!The reshuffle has thrown up several interesting stories, but you seem to have missed all of them. For instance, the PM seems NOT to have all the power, since IDS refused to leave DWP. It seems Osborne wanted him gone because he is refusing to cut benefits any further, saying the working poor can't cope with any further pain.I'm not sure that state school educated Grant Shapps could be described as coming from the same mould as David Cameron! He can certainly communicate on both TV and Radio, something that Sayeeda Warsi has never managed to do. No doubt her new role in the FCO will be despite her own dodgy expenses questions about foreign trips.Anna Soubry and Dan Poulter are both going to be great PUSSs at Health, and Norman Lamb is a much slicker operator than that idiot Simon Burns. As for Hunt, nobody, not even the Labour Party, has ever suggested he wasn't a capable minister. Their concern was about his relationship with NewsCorp. Well News Corp do not run hospitals, unlike most of the companies that Andrew Lansley is tightly involved in. I think that's got to be seen as a good appointment – Hunt can communicate, is calm under pressure, and doesn't disappear when criticised, all things Lansley was unable to do.Ken Clarke the only economically literate member of the cabinet? Well apart from the PM (the E in PPE) and the Business Secretary, whose job in the private sector was as an economist, lets not forget the private sector achievements of the new Chief Whip, and I always felt that Phillip Hammond was a terrific Shadow Chief Secretary, so his economic input around the table will help as well.Back to what I perceive is your central problem with Cameron. You say his Government doesn't reflect Conservative members. Well that's a shock! The Tories didn't win in 2010, as you keep reminding him, and therefore they are in coalition. So his Government is never going to be the same as it would be with a majority Tory Govt. But your analysis of why the Tories didn't win is flawed – all elections are won from the centre, suggesting the Tories could win by shifting back to the right is the same tired arguments we used to be frustrated with before Cameron – Hague tried it, IDS tried it, Michael Howard tried it. They all failed. You don't win British elections from the right. They win elections from the centre. If Shapps wants to tell the voluntary party that, he is right. And lots of them would understand that. The only reason you didn't win in 2010 was that you were simply too far behind – both in terms of seats from 2005 and in terms of persuading the voters that Tory MPs no longer want to bite the heads off babies.Of course the most important changes that Shapps could bring in would be a fundamental shift in the way the professional party is run – making sure that marginal seats the party needs to win to get a majority have professional staff and proper financial resources, rather than seats like Buckingham rolling in money whilst others don't have two buttons to rub together.IF Ben Gummer receives a phone call from Downing Street, lets hope he hangs up on them. If he decides to go off to Whitehall, he can kiss goodbye to a second term. Ellesmere would walk into the seat in 2015.If it was me, I wouldn't have moved either Andrew Mitchell or Justine Greening. I think the installation of Matt Hancock and Mike Fallon in BIS is going to make a big difference. I'd have brought in Priti Patel and Dominic Raab, rather than Nick Boles, and I'd have sacked Francis Maude, but then you know my feelings about that blithering idiot. I don't like Chris Grayling, he gives me the creeps, and I think he should have looked to promoting more women. But all in all I think Cameron has made the best of a difficult job.

  2. Good comment, Ben. What does Clarke really know about economics – apart from taking all the credit for Norman Lamont's recovery whilst working as little as possible?

  3. Thanks Ben, that brightened up my morning!

  4. Ben 'what a load of old tripe' is a pretty pathetic response to someone who expresses a different political opinion to you, even if you are a political anorak. I could go line by line through your comments expressing differing views – although I wouldn't belittle them by calling them rubbish – but I don't have the time plus I think for a lot of these appointments we are going to have to see how people do. However, I think the fact that Cameron has brought in more right-wing leaning people into more prominent positions shows he is starting to realise that things are not going at all well for his Government. You say that we failed with Hague, IDS and Howard by trying to shift to the right (although I wouldn't say IDS really attempted a shift to the right) and that we will only win elections from the centre. I agree with you about winning from the centre but that centre is a very large range and I also believe that in 2010 the Conservative campaign was fought from the wrong part of it. The country was in a very different place in 1997, 2001 and 2005, than in 2010. Clinton's campaign message 'the economy stupid' hit the nail on the head as that is what affects people the most when it comes to voting. I believe the Conservatives were not too far behind to win in 2010 – people were not still thinking that Tories were evil (apart from the Left who will always think that and never vote Conservative) they just wanted someone to sort out the economy, and if a decent campaign had showed the public that a Conservative government would have tackled this head on then they would have provided a working majority with no problem. Unfortunately if Cameron has now realised that then I think it is too late and I'm not convinced that this reshuffle is going to save him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s