Gavin Maclure's Musings

My take on politics locally, nationally and internationally

Police and Crime Commissioners are a danger to our democracy


I wouldn’t blame you if you had missed an important event taking place this week considering the almost zero publicity from the Coalition Government. This Thursday 15th November, you will be asked to vote for a Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) if you live in England and Wales, excluding London.

The newly elected PCC will replace the Police Authority, which are now abolished. I first wrote about this new role back in May 2011 after the House of Lords defeated the Coalition Government’s first go at the legislation. Needless to say the Government tweaked a few things and got it through the House of Lords the second time. I wrote then I was not in favour of the role and it was actually quite dangerous for our democracy to put all the powers the Police Authority had in the hands of one individual. I still stand by that view.
This was Conservative-proposed legislation but got through the House of Commons with Liberal Democrat votes. The PCC elections were meant to take place in May – at the same time as the Local Council elections – when the evenings are lighter but the yellow peril forced David Cameron to move the elections to November to deliberately lower the turn out as this would benefit them politically. Not because the Liberal Democrats have candidates – they certainly don’t have one in Ipswich – but they are trying to kill the legislation at birth through an abysmally low turnout which won’t give a mandate to the new Commissioner. 
This a very dangerous game to play. The police are an important part of our society and as such must be held accountable to the people. This week may see accountability removed. The Police Authorities were made up of multiple councillors with the number of seats held by the political parties reflecting their share of the vote in the County or Metropolitan council elections. Now, just one person will have the police budget powers and they may be elected by less than 20% of registered voters. 
Great Britain’s police are the envy of the world, with policing by consent of the people a core tenet of our society. On Thursday, the upholding of that consent will be taken away from a representative Police Authority and put in the hands of one man or woman. We are soon to enter dangerous waters.

Author: gavinmaclure

IT professional; political blogger, former Conservative councillor

3 thoughts on “Police and Crime Commissioners are a danger to our democracy

  1. They are an idea from "The Plan" – I thought you liked Douglas Carswell.

  2. Don't fall into the socialist trap Stephen that being a member of a political party means you all have to think the same. That's what Labour members are like. We Conservatives are individuals. Agree with a lot Douglas says but I don't agree with PCCs for the reasons I outline in my post.I will vote though, as is my civic duty.

  3. I agree that putting it in the hands of one person is dangerous – like many I'd have preferred directly elected Police Authority. But to suggest that the PA is representative is to misunderstand the role. The PA is staffed by those dependent on their group leader on the County Council for patronage. There is NO accountability whatsoever. This year the PA voted to increase your council tax Gavin. Do you feel you're getting a better service from our police force? I don't. I've had a neighbour thrown through a plate glass window after a domestic assault and the street sealed off following an suspected gunman. Yet we only see the police round here when they're responding to a crime. A democratically elected person would be accountable for the service the constabulary provides. They would be answerable for why the council tax goes up but the service doesn't. Crucially we can throw them out in 4 years time.Our police are a triumph here in Suffolk. We don't have the same issues that the old West Midlands Crime Squad had. We are lucky that we've never seen the cover ups like Hillsborough, or the killing of Jean-Charles de Menezes, or the killing of Ian Tomlinson. But all these things happened despite the old system of Police Authorities and before them, Police Committees. This, the biggest reform of Criminal Justice in decades, will mean someone can be held accoutable when our police screw up. About time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s